Is Mazda A Good Car Brand? An In-Depth Look

Purchasing a new vehicle is one of the biggest investments you’ll make, so you want to ensure you choose a reliable brand that fits your needs and budget. If you’ve been considering a Mazda, you may be wondering – is Mazda a good car?

The short answer is yes, Mazdas are generally good cars from a reputable brand known for affordable pricing, stylish designs, fun driving dynamics and respectable reliability ratings, especially with their newer models.

However, there are some potential downsides to be aware of when it comes to Mazda, including higher-than-average repair costs compared to non-luxury brands like Honda and Toyota. There are also certain models and years that have proven more problematic than others.

This in-depth guide will provide all the information you need to determine if a Mazda vehicle is the right choice for you. We’ll examine Mazda’s brand reputation, safety ratings, reliability scores, cost of ownership, pros and cons, and much more. Whether you’re looking at a used or new Mazda, this guide will ensure you make an informed decision.

Mazda Brand Overview and History

Founded in 1920 in Hiroshima, Japan, Mazda (originally called Toyo Cork Kogyo Co.) has grown from manufacturing machine tools to becoming one of the most popular Asian car brands worldwide. Known for implementing innovative technologies like the rotary engine and SKYACTIV suite, Mazda has built a reputation for creating fun-to-drive yet affordable vehicles designed with a keen eye for style.

Today, Mazda’s lineup ranges from the iconic MX-5 Miata sports car to crossovers like the compact CX-30 and three-row CX-9. While not a premium luxury brand, Mazdas are positioned as slightly upscale mainstream vehicles compared to non-luxury rivals from companies like Toyota, Honda, Hyundai and Kia.

How Reliable are Mazdas Compared to Other Brands?

When shopping for a new vehicle, reliability is one of the most important factors to consider. Based on data from multiple trusted sources, Mazda ranks as an above-average brand for dependability compared to other mainstream brands:

RepairPal Rating: 4.0/5.0 – This ranks Mazda the 5th most reliable out of 32 brands, based on annual repair costs, severity of repairs, and the number of unscheduled repair trips.
Consumer Reports: Ranked #3 – In their 2022 Auto Reliability Report, Consumer Reports rated Mazda as the 3rd most reliable brand out of 28 major carmakers. This was a significant improvement from previous years.
J.D. Power Vehicle Dependability Study: Above Average – In J.D. Power’s 2023 study assessing problems per 100 vehicles, Mazda scored better than the industry average, though it didn’t rank as high as brands like Lexus, Kia and Toyota.

So while Mazda isn’t necessarily the #1 most dependable choice across the board, most data shows the brand ranking in the top 25% of major automakers for predicted reliability and low repair rates.

The one caveat is that data can vary by model and model year. Some specific Mazda vehicles have proven far more reliable than others over the years. That’s why it’s important to look at ratings for each individual model you’re considering.

Most Reliable Mazda Models

Based on analysis from organizations like Consumer Reports, J.D. Power, RepairPal and others, these Mazda models have consistently ranked among the brand’s most dependable:

Mazda MX-5 Miata

The iconic Miata sports car is Mazda’s most reliable model according to RepairPal and many other sources. It boasts a stellar reputation for dependability thanks to its relatively simple drivetrain and lack of complex electronics that can cause headaches. The MX-5 Miata has been a continual winner of awards from J.D. Power for quality and dependability in the sporty car category.

Mazda CX-5

Mazda’s popular compact crossover SUV also earns high praise for its reliability. RepairPal gave the CX-5 a 4.5/5.0 rating, ranking it #1 among compact SUVs. Both Consumer Reports and J.D. Power have named the CX-5 as the most reliable vehicle in its class multiple times in recent years.

Mazda CX-3

This subcompact crossover is one of Mazda’s most dependable small SUVs, with Consumer Reports listing it as a “Recommended” buy for superior reliability and owner satisfaction scores. RepairPal also rates the CX-3 well above average with a 4.5/5.0 score.

Mazda2

As an affordable subcompact hatchback, the Mazda2 might seem like an unremarkable choice. However, the simple, lightweight design contributes to impressive dependability. RepairPal rates it 4.5 out 5.0, while Consumer Reports calls it one of the most reliable tiny cars you can buy.

Mazda3

Rounding out the most reliable Mazda models is the Mazda3 compact sedan and hatchback. Boasting athletic driving dynamics and premium interior quality for the class, the Mazda3 has scored well above average reliability ratings from most major sources. Both Consumer Reports and RepairPal deem it a smart pick for dependability.

Least Reliable Mazda Models to Avoid

On the flip side, there are a few Mazda nameplates that have proven more troublesome over the years in terms of poor reliability ratings, repair problems and owner complaints:

Mazda6 Sedan

While still a well-equipped and stylish mid-size sedan, the Mazda6 has suffered from a number of issues and recalls, especially in older models like the 2009-2012 generations. Issues have included excessive oil consumption, transmission problems, rust issues and more. RepairPal gives the Mazda6 a below-average 2.5/5.0 reliability rating.

Mazda MPV Minivan

Mazda’s discontinued minivan model was applauded for its performance but also saddled with a variety of electrical, transmission and general dependability issues that made it less reliable than competitors like the Honda Odyssey. Numerous recalls and repair trips plagued this model every year it was produced from 1988-2006.

Mazda Tribute SUV

As an affordable SUV related to the Ford Escape, the Mazda Tribute offered nice features for the money. However, critics dinged the Tribute for poor predicted reliability scores during its production run from 2001–2011. Issues ranged from transmission woes to engine problems and excessive brake wear.

While there are some Mazda lemons to be aware of, the brand as a whole has made impressive strides in improving overall reliability in recent years. Newer models like the CX-30, CX-50 and CX-90 are stacking up very well in quality ratings from the start.

Common Mazda Issues and Problems

Even the most reliable vehicles can still experience issues from time to time. Based on repair data and owner complaints, here are some of the most common Mazda problems you may encounter:

Brake Issues: Complaints of brake booster failure, causing brakes to become very stiff, are frequent in certain Mazda models. This repair can cost over $1,000 if not under warranty.
Clutch Problems: Early 2000s Mazdas like the Mazda3 and Mazda6 were plagued with faulty clutches that wore out prematurely, sometimes as early as 30,000 miles. This very expensive issue seems to have been corrected in later model years.
Engine Concerns: Excessive oil consumption leading to engine failure is one of the scarier recurring issues with some Mazda engines. Other problems include botched timing chains/belts and issues with ignition coils.
Transmission Troubles: Complaints of rough shifting, slippage and even complete transmission failure have plagued certain Mazda models. This can potentially cost $3,500+ to repair out-of-warranty.
Melting Dashboards: Believe it or not, there are reports of Mazda dashboards melting or becoming extremely shiny in hot climates due to subpar materials.
Water Pump Leaks: Debris caught in the pump can cause coolant to leak, resulting in engine damage if not replaced quickly. This afflicts the Mazda CX-9 SUV frequently.
Takata Airbag Recalls: Like many brands, Mazdas were impacted by the widespread Takata airbag recalls that affected millions of vehicles. Models like the Mazda6, CX-7, CX-9 and RX-8 were included due to the risk of the airbag inflators rupturing and causing injury or death upon deployment.

While some of these issues affect specific Mazda models more than others, it’s important to have any open recalls addressed by an authorized Mazda dealer. Many of the problems can be attributed to earlier designs, as Mazda has made strides to improve quality, durability and reliability in recent years.

Average Repair Costs for Mazda Vehicles

According to RepairPal’s analysis, the average annual repair cost for a Mazda is around $462. This places the brand right in the middle of the pack compared to other mainstream, non-luxury brands.

About 10% of the repair visits for a Mazda will be for more severe “severe” issues with a potential repair cost over $1,000. In general though, most scheduled maintenance and repairs will fall into the “affordable” category for the average Mazda owner.

Keeping up with the factory recommended maintenance schedule is key to minimizing repair costs and extending your Mazda’s lifespan. This includes routine services like:

Oil changes
Air filter replacements
Tire rotations
Brake inspections/flushes
Timing belt/chain replacements
Coolant system flushes

While parts and labor costs at the dealership can be pricier, proper maintenance from factory-trained Mazda technicians can prevent much larger repair bills down the road.

Mazda Safety Ratings and Driver Assist Technology

Safety should be a top priority when selecting a new vehicle. Thankfully, Mazda earns strong ratings and offers robust safety tech to give you peace of mind:

IIHS Safety Ratings The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) has awarded its coveted TOP SAFETY PICK+ designation to multiple recent Mazda models, including:

2023 Mazda3 Sedan/Hatchback
2023/2024 Mazda CX-30
2023 Mazda CX-5
2024 Mazda CX-50

These models earned top “Good” scores in all six IIHS crashworthiness tests, as well as a “Superior” rating for front crash prevention capabilities.

NHTSA Crash Tests Similarly, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has awarded 5-star overall safety ratings (out of 5 stars) to the current Mazda3, CX-30 and CX-5 for stellar front, side and rollover crash protection.

Standard Safety Tech Mazda makes advanced driver assistance systems standard across its lineup. I-ACTIVSENSE safety features bundled on most models include:

Forward collision warning with automatic emergency braking
Blind spot monitoring
Rear cross-traffic alert
Lane departure warning
Lane keeping assistance
Adaptive cruise control
Automatic high beams

Upper trim levels offer additional high-tech safety aids like a 360-degree camera system, front and rear parking sensors, traffic sign recognition and more. Overall, Mazda provides a strong safety package for the mainstream vehicle segments.

How Well Do Mazdas Retain Their Value?

While not quite as impressive as brands like Toyota and Honda, Mazdas hold their value reasonably well compared to other mainstream brands. Factors like Mazda’s focus on premium styling and materials contribute to better-than-average residual values.

According to automotive research firms like ALG, these were some of the highest-ranked Mazda models for resale value after 3 years:

Mazda MX-5 Miata: 66% residual value
Mazda CX-5: 57%
Mazda CX-30: 56%
Mazda3: 53%

After 5 years of ownership, the data indicates most Mazda models will retain around 40-50% of their original value, give or take. This places Mazda in the top 25% of mainstream brands for resale value rating.

To maximize your Mazda’s residual value, be sure to stick to the maintenance schedule, keep complete records, avoid major repairs if possible, and purchase a lower-mileage used model to begin with.

The Pros and Cons of Owning a Mazda

To summarize the main pros and cons of purchasing a Mazda vehicle:

Pros of Owning a Mazda

Stylish, sporty exterior designs
Fun, engaging driving dynamics
More affordable pricing than luxury brands
Focus on fuel efficiency across the lineup
Nicer interiors with premium materials compared to non-luxury rivals
Strong residual value ratings
Good safety scores and standard driver assist tech

Potential Cons of Mazdas

Not as dependable long-term as Honda, Toyota according to data
Higher average repair costs compared to non-luxury brands
Lacking the latest advanced tech like digital gauge clusters
interior space and storage cubbies are tighter than some competitors
Limited hybrid/EV powertrain options currently

Overall, a new Mazda represents a great value proposition if you want a blend of style, driving enjoyment and dependability without overpaying. It’s a smart alternative to luxury brands from Europe and high-end Asian automakers.

So How Long Do Mazdas Last?

With proper care and maintenance, most modern Mazdas should realistically last 200,000 miles or more before major repairs are needed. Specific models like the MX-5 Miata, CX-5 and Mazda6 have proven to be long-haulers in their segments.

The expected lifespan can range from 13-17 years or 200,000-300,000 miles for a well-maintained Mazda. This places the brand in the upper tier of mainstream non-luxury brands for longevity when the vehicles are cared for properly.

As with most cars, the key to maximizing your Mazda’s lifespan is adhering to the maintenance schedule for oil changes, timing belt replacements, fluid flushes and more. Proper maintenance is especially crucial if you plan to keep your Mazda for 10+ years.

In Conclusion

After an in-depth look at Mazda’s reliability data, safety scores, ownership costs and other factors – is Mazda a good car brand? Yes, Mazda emerges as a smart choice for those seeking an affordable yet stylish, fun-to-drive and dependable vehicle from a reputable brand that’s not quite luxury-level.

While Mazda may not rank at the absolute top for reliability, the brand is solidly above-average and continually improving with each new generation. Certain models like the MX-5 Miata and CX-5 are class-leaders you can count on. And Mazdas hold their value well while offering robust safety features and driving enjoyment.

There are potential downsides like higher-than-average repair costs for some repairs and dependency on proper maintenance. Luxury brand devotees may find Mazda lacking the latest tech features. But overall, Mazda represents a compelling mix of quality and value that’s hard to beat in the non-premium segments its vehicles compete in.

So if you’re in the market for a stylish, fun-to-drive and reasonably-priced vehicle, Mazda is definitely a brand worth your consideration based on the data. Just be sure to research any specific used model you’re looking at and have a trusted mechanic inspect it. With proper care, a Mazdacan be an excellent long-term investment.